| with the TI-92 David Bowers, University College Suffolk, UK | ![]()
|
Application 2: Demonstrating Visual "Proofs"
Dynamic geometry computer software such as Cabri Geometre, and its version included with
the TI-92, allow students to produce geometric constructions and explore their
properties. Selecting and "dragging" a point is a particularly effective way to verify
that certain properties of the construction continue to hold even when the original
shape is deformed.
Unfortunately, the excitement of seeing the results on the computer or TI-92 screen
cannot be reproduced through printed book pages or worksheets. At best, a sequence of
printed images can be shown, and the reader has to use her imagination.
Within a web document, however, animated GIFs can be created using screendumps from
the TI-92 which show much more realistically the result of dynamic geometry investigations.
For example, the fact that the medians of a triangle are concurrent can be demonstrated
in the image below:
Of course, looking at this animated image does not impart the full excitement of
using the TI-92 itself, since the interactivity of actually choosing a vertex yourself
and deciding where to drag it is not permitted. (We are working on using more
sophisticated programming such as JavaScript.) However, the reader of the web page
can appreciate this visual "proof" without ever having had access to dynamic geometry
software. The author of the web page can always make the animation more impressive by taking the
time to increase the number of screendumps which make up the "slide show", and perhaps
choosing to vary the position of more than one vertex at a time.
Another example of an animated visual "proof" is given below, which demonstrates
that the angle in a semicircle is always equal to 90 degrees. Note that the angle
measuring facility has been used. The speed of the animation has been varied, so that
on the slower run through the reader can verify that the base angles are indeed
complementary.
Another geometrical result which can be verified using dynamic geometry is the fact
that the angle subtended by a chord at the centre of a circle is double the angle
subtended at the far circumference. We choose to present a static screendump of one
particular case, since this result is perhaps more easily explained by example rather
than in words. Note that importing the screendump firstly into a graphics package
allows us to annotate it in colour before saving it in GIF format. Alongside we show
the animated version, where the angle measurements have been dragged to the text:
The "visual proofs" above are taken from the topic of geometry. However, results
from other areas of mathematics can also be demonstrated visually by making use of
animations. In the topic of analysis, it is not expected that students on an introductory
course should prove formally that the Taylor series of a function converges, although
a general understanding of the concept of convergence is required. The animation below
shows the graph of sin(x) successively overlaid by the graphs of higher order Taylor
series approximations, up to the approximation of order 25. This single image within
a web page is both convincing and economical in demonstrating the increasing "goodness"
of the approximation:
|
Application 3: Aiding Conceptual Understanding
A well-known saying claims that "a picture speaks a thousand words". The emphasis that
current mathematics education places on the inter-relationship between data, functions
and graphs underlines the value of a graphical representation of the functional
relationship between variables.
Two-dimensional graphs of a function of the form y = f(x) are the
traditional fare of elementary mathematics courses. However, computer algebra systems
such as DERIVE and the TI-92 also allow 3D graphs to be produced for functions of the form
  z = f(x,y) which can enrich the experience of students (as well as being
great fun to look at!) A 3D function plot can be best understood by viewing it from
different angles, something which is fairly slow to do using the TI-92 (using "CyclePic")
and which cannot really be appreciated by looking at a sequence of printed graphs on a
page. Look now at the following animation, and be amazed!
Animations based on viewing a 3-D surface plot from various angles in succession
can make the "hidden" features such as peaks and troughs more easy to identify.
Sometimes the effect is not what was anticipated. . . Click here only
if you are over 18 to view a slightly lewd manifestation of a surface plot with
nevertheless interesting mathematical properties!
Students tend to find functions given in parametric form less intuitive and hence
more difficult to visualize and sketch than those in explicit function form . Graphics
calculators can aid understanding by allowing the user to "trace" along the curve and
follow the change in the parameter value. In particular the TI-92 allows a table of
(t,x,y) values to be presented alongside the graph so that the user can appreciate the
independent variation of x(t) and y(t) and how they define the position on the curve.
The printed page of a textbook cannot allow such a graph to be traced out dynamically
in real time, and authors tend to rely on the rather clumsy labelling of "t=-1", "t=0",
"t=1", "t=2" etc at appropriate places along the curve.
However, web pages can
include animated images which can be made to simulate what appears on the TI-92 screen
when investigating the shape of paramteric curves by tracing along and noting the
parameter values:
Similarly, curves given in polar form r = f(q)
can also be reproduced as an animation, illustrating how the distance r from the
origin varies with angle q.
|
Application 4: Visualising Practical Problems
Problem solving in applied maths is often little more than using standard formulae
to set up a system of equations, and then solving them algebraically. Traditional
textbooks do little to encourage a "feeling" or insight into the nature of the problem,
since the visual representation there is restricted to static diagrams. Web pages,
on the other hand, can include animation in the images, which can help to illustrate the
inherent dynamical nature of many problem.
A common topic in applied maths courses concerns the motion of projectiles. For
example, consider the situation where two objects are projected towards each other with
different initial velocities. The problem is to establish whether they collide. In the
case where the objects are projected from ground level 50 metres apart, the first with
initial velocity 20 m/s at 40 degrees to the horizontal, the second with initial
velocity 18 m/s at 60 degrees to the horizontal, the parametric equations of motion
are given by:
A common mistake made by students in this type of problem is to find the equations
of the two parabolic flight paths in the form y = f(x) and calculate
their point of intersection as the point of collision. This error would be reinforced
by the kind of static diagram which is often shown in textbooks, such as: A popular type of mathematical activity to solve problems is simulation.
While simulations can be exciting classroom activities which make use of practical
apparatus or computer software, the results of the simulations can appear rather
uninteresting when presented in writing, since the dynamics of the situation has
been lost. Conversely, it can be difficult to enthuse students to appreciate and
carry out simulations through a written description.
The dynamic features of a
simulation can be captured in an image which is animated rather than static, and an
animated GIF within a web page is a simple way of achieving this. We show below the
running of a simulation of the well-known experiment to estimate the value of pi.
A quadrant of a circle of unit radius is drawn within a unit square, and a number of
points (50, say) are chosen at random within the square. Since the proportion of
the area of the square covered by the quadrant is pi/4, the proportion of the points
lying in the quadrant may also be taken as an estimate of pi/4, from which an
estimate of pi can be deduced.
Taking sets of 50 points, we achieve estimates which are consistently not too far
from the "true" value, and the concept of "not too far" can be discussed. For the
purposes of this paper, we note how an animation produced using the TI-92 can
highlight the dynamic nature of simulations while taking advantage of the TI-92's
accuracy to produce meaningful content. The animation provides a reliable simulation of
an actual simulation!
|
Conclusion
We have identified a variety of topics in mathematics where the provision of a "moving
picture" would help to convey the mathematical properties under consideration:
In all such examples, the dynamics of the situation can be created and demonstrated
using modern teaching technology such as computer algebra systems and geometry software,
both of which are available for computers and also as an integral part of the Texas
Instruments "supercalculator" TI-92. Good classroom practice for teachers and lecturers
is to incorporate the use of this technology, either for whole-class demonstration or
for the students to work with individually.
Unfortunately, the "moving pictures" are dependent on the availability of an
appropriate machine running the appropriate software. (They are also dependent on the
user being able to create or re-create the desired results with the machine.) The other
main medium of learning, namely the printed page of the textbook or worksheet, is not able
to present graphics or images in moving form. It is an increasing anomaly that learning
material which aspires to encourage the use of technology to assist the conceptual
understanding of dynamic processes in mathematics does so by using static printed
screendumps.
The internet now provides a platform for the provision of learning material
in qualitatively new ways. Whereas until only a few years ago the web was restricted
to simple text and pictures, it can now host animation, video and sound without
compromising on the simplicity and essential universality of the browser interface for
the end-user.
In this paper we have endeavoured to show how animated images can be created to
enhance web-based mathematics teaching materials with little need for expertise in
computer programming. An "animated GIF" can be created by putting together a series of
screenshots from the TI-92, using inexpensive and simple graphics tools which are freely
available as shareware.
Although the examples of animations presented in this paper are admittedly not as
sophisticated as many of those seen in commercially produced multimedia CD Roms, there are
two advantages in presenting them in this form.
Firstly, by taking the screenshots directly from the TI-92, we can be sure that the
images are mathematically accurate and reliable. We are doing no more than replicating
what we would actually be using ourselves in the classroom or lab. Students who were
already familiar with the TI-92 ought to recognise and identify with the animated
images on the web page, and be encouraged to investigate and reproduce the display
next time they have a TI-92 to hand.
Secondly, the ease with which such animations can be produced cannot be overstressed.
It is our contention that, as the internet continues to gain popularity as an
educational medium, teachers will become accustomed to producing one-off web pages for
student "consumption" just as they nowadays think nothing of wordprocessing a paper
handout. (Do you remember that quantum leap when you first wordprocessed a worksheet
for your students rather than handwriting or typing it?)
The power of the TI-92 and the efficiency of the TI-GRAPHLINK, together with the
enthusiasm of the educator and the open standards of the world wide web, can contribute
to new standards of mathematics learning material which incorporate the dynamic features
now available in computer algebra systems and other mathematical software.
|
References
One of the easiest to use GIF Animators is the GIF Construction Set from
Alchemy Mindworks Inc. Their website has a variety of examples and demos: Version 5 of the popular graphics software package Paint Shop Pro includes
the application Animation Shop, which guides you through the creation of animated
GIFs. Descriptions of a variety of web graphics tools, including reviews of several GIF
animators, can be found at: An example of online learning material which includes static screendumps from the
TI-92 where animated images might be more instructive, can be found at: And finally, the website of the machine which makes it all possible: |
Notes on the Author
Recent relevant publications:
Bowers, D. (1995) "Computer Algebra in the Classroom", Mathematics Support Newsletter, 3.
Bowers, D. (1995) "What was the Question?", International DERIVE Journal, 2(2).
Bowers, D. (1995) "Changing Assessment Criteria in A-level Mathematics with DERIVE", in:
Barzel, B. (Ed), Tagungsband der Derive Days Düsseldorf, Landesmedienzentrum
Rheinland-Pfalz.
Bowers, D. & Townsley-Kulich, L. (1996) "Total Resource Management" in: Monaghan, J. (Ed)
The State of Computer Algebra in Mathematics Education, Chartwell-Bratt, UK.
Bowers, D. & Beaudin, M. (1996) "Logistics for facilitating CAS Instruction" in: Monaghan, J. (Ed)
The State of Computer Algebra in Mathematics Education, Chartwell-Bratt, UK.
Bowers, D. (1997) "Computer Algebra and Secret Codes", Micromath, 13(2).
Bowers, D. (1997) "What was the Question - A Framework for Investigational Activities using
DERIVE" in: Graham, E. (Ed) Mathematical Activities with DERIVE, Chartwell-Bratt, UK.
Bowers, D. (1997) "Maths Support for Students with Visual Impairment", Mathematics Support
Newsletter, 6.
Bowers, D. (1997) "Opportunities for the Use of Computer Algebra Systems in Middle Secondary
Mathematics in England and Wales", Zentralblatt für Didaktik der Mathematik 97/4
Recent relevant conference papers
"Enhancing the quality of student-centred mathematics": 27th International Conference of the Association for Educational and Training Technology, York, UK, 6-9 April 1992.
"The use of authoring software to enhance the quality of student-centred mathematics provision": International Conference on Technology in Mathematics Teaching, Birmingham, UK,
17-20 September 1993.
"What was the question? Structured investigational activities using DERIVE": The First International DERIVE Conference, Plymouth, UK, 11-15 July 1994.
"Customised studyware in mathematics": The Seventh International Conference on Technology in Collegiate Mathematics, Orlando, USA, 17-20 November 1994.
"Die Erweiterung des Erwartungshorizonts durch DERIVE": International Council for Computer Algebra in Mathematics Education, Düsseldorf, Germany, 19-21 April 1995.
"Attracting teachers to DERIVE": International Symposium of the Austrian Centre for the Didactics of Computer Algebra, Honolulu, USA, 30 July - 3 August 1995.
"Computer-based studyware in mathematics": International Conference on Technology in Mathematics Teaching, Edinburgh, UK, 4-7 September 1995.
"On establishing a mathematics workshop": Second National Conference on Support for Mathematics in Further & Higher Education, Luton, UK, 14 September 1995.
"On Plotting Piecewise Defined Functions": DERIVE/TI-92 Days Leeds, Leeds, UK, 13-15 April 1996.
"Exploiting DERIVE's Vector Function": The Second International DERIVE Conference, Bonn, Germany, 2-6 July 1996
"Animating Web Pages with the TI-92": The Third International DERIVE Conference, Gettysburg, USA, 14-17 July 1998
Contact details
David Bowers The URL of this document is http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/davidbowers/
|