Sgt. Tommy Prince: the most decorated Canadian Aboriginal veteran

A biography and tribute, Part II

---

contents

__Between the Wars__

__Korea and the pain of War__

__Prince's Korean service record, medals and decorations__

__Tommy Prince in post-war Canada__

__Epilogue: Aboriginal veteran's legacy lives on__

__Aboriginal Veterans Scholarship Trust__

__References__

__Further reading: literature, video__

__Student / Educator resources__

__Contact information__

__site index__


---

Between the Wars

Tom Prince worked as a Lumberjack, though he found the job no longer suited him. The Department of Veteran Affairs granted him some funds to start a maintenance business. Prince was typical of the many Indian veterans who became actively involved in hearings on the Indian Act held by a joint committee of the Senate and the House of Commons in 1946-47. The hearings resulted, to a considerable extent, from efforts by Canada’s Indians during the war. Prince was among the WWII Aboriginal veterans who achieved some prominence in the political scene.

Tommy was well spoken, and gave lengthy testimony at hearings in 1946-47, representing his own band (as Chief, according to the proceedings of the hearings), as well as the Indian Association of Manitoba. The committee was extremely impressed with him. Part of his strategies and goals, were in raising agricultural production aggressively on the reserve and working toward elimination of the Indian Act. Some of his people did not agree with him in all respects of his testimony.

The government was slow to respond and little progress was made in his requests. Leaving the position, he was unable to continue his business, which had failed during his absence from it.

He became increasingly frustrated with his inability to bring about change in the immediate post-war years, and his life exemplifies the many frustrations and struggles facing returning veterans.

---

Korea and the pain of War

Two of the 11 medals Tommy Prince earned during his military career - the Korea Medal and the United Nations Service Medal - were for service during the U.N. operations in Korea. In August 1950, one week after the government announced its decision to form the Special Force, Tommy at 34 years old, once again volunteered. A decade had past since he'd first been accepted into the military. He joined the 2nd Battalion, Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry (PPCLI), the first Canadian Army unit to arrive in the region.

Prince was in action quickly. In February 1951, the Patricias joined the 27th Commonwealth Brigade on the battlefield. Soon after arriving in the war zone, the sergeant, who was second in command of a rifle platoon, led an evening "snatch patrol" of eight men into an enemy camp. The raid was a success; the group returned before dawn with two captured machine-guns.

Prince was with the 2nd Battalion PPCLI when, together with the 3rd Royal Australian Regiment, it was awarded the United States' Presidential Unit Citation for distinguished service in the Kapyong valley April 24 and 25, 1951, during one of the toughest actions of the war. The Patricias were to hold a defensive position at Hill 677 so that a South Korean division could withdraw during an attack by Chinese and North Korean forces. Although at one point the battalion was surrounded and resupply of ammunition and emergency rations could only be accomplished by air, the Patricias held their ground. The enemy withdrew. Ten PPCLI men were killed and 23 were wounded during the two-day battle. The award was a first for a Canadian unit.

Prince's time at the front was intense, but brief. His knees were subject to painful swelling and premature arthritis. It was a struggle for him to endure the constant, steep climbing demanded by the Korean landscape. After a medical examination in May 1951, he was hospitalized and then assigned administrative duties. In August, he returned to Canada.

Prince remained on active service as an administrative sergeant at Camp Borden in Ontario. Here his knees [responded] to the added rest and thus, in March 1952, he volunteered for a second tour of duty in the Far East. He sailed for Korea in October, 1952 with the 3rd Battalion, PPCLI.

The following paragraphs of dialogue and commentary are controversial, and based on interviews, a film documentary and published accounts. More information is vitally necessary, through research and testimonials of facts, with respect toTom Prince's medical condition, his subsequent return to Korea, events that took place there, and post military issues.

Regarding Prince's second tour in Korea, Peacock explains:

"In my mind, he should have never gone back for the second tour in Korea..my personal view, that the man was worn out psychologically, and the [people] that sent him back..well.. were they criminal? They probably thought they were doing him a favour".

In November 1952, the training of 3rd Battalion PPCLI in Korea, was interrupted by fighting on "the Hook", a key position west of the Sami-chon River that overlooked much of the rear areas of the U.N. forces. When a Chinese battalion gained a foothold on the forward positions of another U.N. unit on November 18, the 3rd PPCLI was ordered to help defend the sector. By dawn of the 19th, the U.N. unit, with assistance from the Patricias, had recaptured the post. Five Patricias were killed on the Hook and nine were wounded, Sergeant Prince sustained a leg injury.

Claude Petit ,(Korean war veteran):
"He was in there [a cave dug-out , protection from the shelling] picking out shrapnel with a bayonet, in his leg, somebody had told him to go back.. take a look at it..he said, Hell, I don't have time for that, ... that's just the kind of guy he was." He was hospitalized for a period, later returning to active duty.

Robert Peacock (Platoon Commander):
"Tommy was always pushing, pushing.., he had a reputation to maintain.. and he shouldn't to me, have been pushed or allowed to be pushed, into his final [bit] where he literally collapsed... it was too bad, because, it was a great legend there."

Narrative excerpt from the film documentary, "Fallen Hero":
The moment of 'collapse' came when Prince led a fighting patrol back to camp, his patrol had been ambushed..and Prince was shaken. He insisted that all his men were accounted for, but he'd forgotten a wounded soldier in the field.

Don Ardelian (Platoon Sgt), was to go back with a search party to rescue the missing man.
Ardelian: "The people he was working for directly, which would have been, the Intelligence and Operation Officers, should have realized that this individual was been pushed to the edge.."

Film narrative excerpt:
"Prince was arrested for leaving someone behind, and then claiming his patrol was complete..later the charges were dropped. It was clear that Prince was suffering from battle fatigue after so many years in the heat of war."

Don Ardelian (Platoon Sgt): "In my view, that was a sad sad situation, here was a fine outstanding soldier, one of the best this country has ever produced, and [we] let it end that way.. it didn't have to be that way at all, in my view, if his officers had been on top of the job, they would have had 'indicators' that they were working this one too far, it's not going to make it.. and he didn't, after that he was sent off to some administrative job.."

Prince recovered from the injury, but began to have continual difficulties with his arthritic knees. Between January and April he spent several weeks in hospital. In July 1953, the Korea Armistice was signed, and, the following November, Prince returned to Canada. The sergeant remained in the army, and was assigned as an instructor of new recruits in Winnipeg. Ultimately, Tommy's arthritic knees would result in being discharged from the armed forces in 1954.

---

Tommy Prince - His Service Record, Medals and Decorations

Korea

Length of Service:

August 14, 1950 - October 28, 1953

Units & Regiments:

2nd Battalion, Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry
3rd Battalion, PPCLI

Theatre of Service:

Korea.

Medals & Decorations

War Medal, Korean Medal, Korea Volunteer Medal 1950 - 1954,
United Nation's Service Medal.


Prince's life in post-war Canada

After leaving the service, Tom and Verna Sinclair over seven years, raised and provided a home for five children, including two daughters Beryl and Beverly.

Tommy had moved the family, to and from Winnipeg and the reserve, wherever he could secure work. In June of 1955, at the age of 39, Tommy made the news [for heroism], when he saved a man from drowning at the Alexander Docks in Winnipeg.

Though by 1961, seven years after leaving the military service, he was facing alcohol addiction, poverty due to racial, employment discrimination. In addition to arthritis in his knees, he was having sleep difficulties.
Three years later, in 1964, he and Verna separated. Alcohol related abuse, against her and the children, has been alleged. Tommy stayed in touch with the children as long as possible, inevitably, they drifted apart. The children were taken by "Child and Family Services", and placed in foster homes. Tommy was now facing the loneliness, of being isolated from his children, whom he still spoke of fondly.

Claude Petit, (Korean war veteran):
"I was hearing that he was drinking quite heavily and down on skid road, 'hawked' his medals and 'everything else', it's bad stuff, you know.. the thing is, somebody should have.. especially the [regiment].. he spent his life in there, that's all he knew.. You get into the system, [the Army system] The routine.. and that's probably why he...wouldn't hang on to a job, or he got fired and would start 'boozing'.. That's bad stuff, they should have took care of him"

Prince's son, Tommy jr. had lived with his father in Winnipeg for several years in the 1970's. After many years of separation, his daughter Beryl at 17, had an emotional reunion with her father. She had been searching for him and found him at 'Harbour Light', the Salvation Army Hostel.

Ironically, though Tommy's life had become extremely tragic, he was was remembered during ceremonies. The PPCLI honoured Sgt. Tommy Prince on Remembrance Day, and on special ceremonial occasions. On August 1975, 30 years since the end of WWII, a special salute and citation were given by the 2nd Battalion PPCLI at the Brokenhead Reserve in Manitoba, during an Indian Days celebration and in October of 1976, a Certificate of Merit was presented to Tom in recognition of his years of dedicated service to the Aboriginal people of Manitoba.

Sadly, Tommy Prince spent his last years as an alcoholic, trying to ease loneliness and cope with the physical pain of his chronically arthritic knees.
He resided in the Salvation Army, Social Service Centre, in October 1977.
As an alcohol-free man, he passed away November 25, 1977 at the Deer Lodge Hospital, with daughters Beryl and Beverly at his side.

With credit to Tommy's aunt, she pressed the government and military to fully recognize, one of Canada's most decorated soldiers. As a result of the efforts of the Prince family, the military relented. Sgt Prince would be given a memorial service with full military honours.

At his funeral, a delegation of the Princess Patricias served as pallbearers and draped a Canadian flag over his coffin for the memorial service.

As the trumpeter finished, five young men from the Brokenhead Indian Reserve began to chant the melancholy "Death of a Warrior" song, as drummers beat a sad lament. ...along with family, the crowd of over 500 included , people from all walks of life: active soldiers, veterans, Manitoba's Lieutenant-Governor Jobin, consuls representing France, Italy and the United States, farmers, fishermen, trappers, businessmen and many many others.

"Tommy Prince was a courageous, admirable and able man. He is a legend.. The leadership he extended beyond his culture is a gift to be acknowleged and honoured. He gave his all for his home and country." Doris Small

---

Epilogue: Aboriginal veteran's legacy lives on

Prince had always asserted that he was in the war to prove to the world that his people were just as good as any others and fully deserving of equality.

The heroic efforts during the wars did not achieve his goal of seeing his people become true equals in Canada. The National Indian Brotherhood (now the Assembly of First Nations) recognized his efforts, as well as those of Walter Deiter and Omer Peters, among others, paying tribute to these veterans through the establishment of the Heroes of Our Time Native Scholarship series. The Assembly of First Nations administers this important fund today, linking Indian veteran political leaders with the present generation.

Aboriginal Veterans fought and lost their lives in three wars and various military actions on behalf of Canada. Many were decorated as heroes, but upon their return home, they were unable to obtain the same benefits which other Veterans enjoyed. Further, these Veterans had to extinguish their aboriginal rights, preventing them from returning to their own communities to live.

Continuing the efforts, Senator Leonard Marchand brought this grave injustice to the attention of The Hon. Ronald A. Irwin, former Minister of INAC. Working with The Hon. Anne McLellan, former Minister of Natural Resources and Federal Interlocutor for Métis and Non-Status Indians, and Aboriginal Veterans groups, the federal Government has established the
Aboriginal Veterans Scholarship Trust with a contribution of $1.15 million..

Senator Leonard Marchand receives, recognition for contribution to the Aboriginal community
at the 5th Annual (2001) ANTCO/ANDEVCO Business and Community Service Awards.


References

Small, Doris. Sgt Tommy Prince
http://www.mala.bc.ca/~soules/media112/zine2000/small/princem.htm

Whitlock, Flint. An American perspective--a history of the 1st Special Service Force
http://www.thehistorynet.com/WorldWarII/articles/2000/0100_cover.htm

(The) Final Report of the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples (RCAP)

Vol1 Ch12 s1 to s3
Vol1 Ch12 s4 to s4.4
Vol1 Ch12 s4.5 to s6


Gaffen Fred, Forgotten Soldiers

Milloy, John,
Cross Cultural Relations and Criminal Justice in Manitoba 1670-1949

(Winnipeg: Aboriginal Justice Inquiry of Manitoba, 1990)

Minister of Supply and Services Canada 1993
Cat. No. V32-56/1993E ISBN 0-662-19850-6

Porter Mackenzie, "Warrior: Tommy Prince",
Maclean’s 65/17 (September 1952).

---

Further reading: literature, video

Adleman, Robert & Walton, George
The Devil's Brigade

Burhans, Robert D.
The First Special Service Force : a war history of the North Americans, 1942-1944

Sealey, D. Bruce,Van de Vyvere, Peter
Thomas George Prince

Williams, Jeffery
Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry

Fallen Hero: The Tommy Prince Story, 1999
  http://www.filmwest.com/subjects/canadian.htm
Filmwest Associates Distribution Ltd.

Tommy Prince's medals are authenticated and returned to family

---

Student / Educator resources

BC First Nations Studies 12
Curriculum: Leadership and Self-Determination II
http://www.bced.gov.bc.ca/irp/bcfns12/lasd1.htm

excerpts:
Prescribed learning outcomes, It is expected that students will:

* describe the experiences of Aboriginal veterans during
and after the two World Wars and the Korean War

* describe the roles, responsibilities, and achievements of current Aboriginal groups
and leaders, locally, provincially, and nationally

suggested instructional strategies:

* Invite a guest speaker who has knowledge of Aboriginal veterans issues
to explain and answer questions.

* Following a discussion of Aboriginal veterans issues, have students
compose a class letter or e-mail to an MP on the subject.

BC First Nations Studies 12 - Recommended video ...
* Fallen Hero: The Tommy Prince Story
http://www.bced.gov.bc.ca/irp/bcfns12/bcfnsapb.htm

General Description:  This 44-minute documentary presents the story of Tommy Prince, decorated World War II and Korean War hero. It focuses on his life and his lasting legacy, tracing his story from the poverty of the reserve through war hero, to the tragedy of his post-military experience.

Producers summary:

Tommy Prince was a man of incredible drive and ambition, with the keenest instincts, the sharpest eye and strong leadership qualities. His name is well known across Canada,
both for his unprecedented accomplishments and as a metaphor for the hypocrisy and prejudices of Canadian society.
Many stories have explored Tommy's past, but this documentary focuses on his life and his lasting legacy. His story, from the poverty of his isolated reserve, through becoming a war hero, twice over, to the minefield of being an Indian in Canada is a journey of epic proportions.

Caution: This video depicts sensitive social issues, including alcohol abuse and family dysfuntion. Teachers will wish to develop appropriate pre- and post-viewing discussion and activities to set the context of these sensitive issues.

Filmwest Associates Distribution Ltd.
http://www.filmwest.com/subjects/canadian.htm
http://www.bclc.bc.ca/TitleF.htm (purchasing info)

---
Dr. Susan Neylan : History of the Native Peoples of Canada
http://www.interchange.ubc.ca/sneylan/hist302.htm

Dr. Susan Neylan : Aboriginal Veterans: Lest We Forget
http://www.interchange.ubc.ca/sneylan/vet.htm


| Contact information |

http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/aboriginal/prince2.htm
©copyright 2001 Vancouver Cartography Net

site index