------------------------------------------------------------------------
U.S. District Court
Western District of New York (Buffalo)
CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 99-CV-32
Zarembka, et al v. State of New York, et al
Filed: 01/14/99
Assigned to: Senior USDJ John T. Curtin
Demand: $192,000,000
Nature of Suit: 895
Lead Docket: None
Jurisdiction: Federal Question
Dkt# in other court: None
Cause: 29:621 Job Discrimination (Age)
DATE # DOCKET ENTRY
1/14/99 1 COMPLAINT filed; FILING FEE $ 150 RECEIPT # 71515 (jd)
[Entry date 01/14/99]
...
9/20/00 47 ORDER, plaintiffs may File second amended class action
complaint through counsel of record or file individual
complaints pro se by 10/31/00 and defendants [15-1]
motion to Dismiss and [14-1] motion to Dismiss are
dismissed, these motions may be renewed after the second
amended complaint is filed. ( signed by Senior USDJ John T.
Curtin ) Notice and copy of order sent to Anthony J. Brock,
William D. Maldovan, Georgiana H. Jungels, Paul Zarembka (jd)
[Entry date 09/20/00]
10/24/00 48 ORDER, to Extend Time, set Amended Pleadings deadline
to 1/31/01 ( signed by Senior USDJ John T. Curtin ) Notice
and copy of order sent to Anthony J. Brock, James R.
Sandner, William D. Maldovan, Georgiana H. Jungels, Paul
Zarembka (jd) [Entry date 10/24/00]
1/25/01 49 ORDER, granting newly retained attorney Andrew Fleming's
letter request for Extension of Time by 60 days to file
amended complaint ( signed by Senior USDJ John T. Curtin
) Notice and copy of order sent to Anthony J. Brock, James
R. Sandner, William D. Maldovan, Georgiana H. Paul Zarembka
Andrew Fleming (jd) [Entry date 01/25/01]
4/3/01 50 ORDER, to Extend Time, reset Amended Pleadings deadline
to 4/30/01 ( signed by Senior USDJ John T. Curtin ) Notice
and copy of order sent to Anthony J. Brock, James R.
Sandner, William D. Maldovan, Andrew P. Fleming (jd)
[Entry date 04/03/01]
4/30/01 51 AMENDED COMPLAINT by Paul Zarembka , amending [2-1] amended
complaint adding party defendants Linda Agnello, Michael
P. Rowan, Allen C. DeMarco, Walter J. Pellegrini (jd)
[Entry date 04/30/01]
5/18/01 52 ORDER, to Extend Time, reset Answer deadline to 6/29/01
( signed by Senior USDJ John T. Curtin ) Notice and copy
of order sent to Anthony J. Brock, James R. Sandner,
William D. Maldovan, Andrew P. Fleming (jd)
[Entry date 05/18/01]
6/7/01 53 ORDER, to Extend Time, reset Answer deadline to 6/29/01
( signed by Senior USDJ John T. Curtin ) Notice and copy
of order sent to Anthony J. Brock, James R. Sandner,
William D. Maldovan, Andrew P. Fleming (jd)
[Entry date 06/07/01]
6/29/01 54 MOTION by defendants State of New York, Linda Agnello,
Michael P. Rowan, Allen C. DeMarco, Walter J. Pellegrini
to Dismiss second amended complaint with affidavit in
support (jd) [Entry date 07/02/01]
6/29/01 55 MEMORANDUM of LAW by defendants State of New York, Linda
Agnello, Michael P. Rowan, Allen C. DeMarco, Walter J.
Pellegrini in support of [54-1] motion to Dismiss second
amended complaint (jd) [Entry date 07/02/01]
6/29/01 56 MOTION by defendants United Professions, William E.
Scheuerman to Dismiss with affidavit and exhibits in
support (jd) [Entry date 07/02/01]
6/29/01 57 MEMORANDUM of LAW by defendants United Professions,
William E. Scheuerman in support of [56-1] motion to
Dismiss (jd) [Entry date 07/02/01]
6/29/01 58 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by United Professions, William E.
Scheuerman [57-1] support memorandum by William E.
Scheuerman, United Professions, [56-1] motion to Dismiss by
William E. Scheuerman, United Professions (jd)
[Entry date 07/02/01]
7/9/01 59 ORDER, Response to Motion set to 8/1/01 for [56-1] motion
to Dismiss, Reply to Response to Motion set to 8/15/01
for [56-1] motion to Dismiss ( signed by Senior USDJ John
T. Curtin ) Notice and copy of order sent to Anthony J.
Brock, James R. Sandner, William D. Maldovan, Andrew P.
Fleming (jd) [Entry date 07/09/01]
7/9/01 60 ORDER, Response to Motion set to 8/1/01 for [54-1] motion
to Dismiss second amended complaint, Reply to Response to
Motion set to 8/15/01 for [54-1] motion to Dismiss second
amended complaint ( signed by Senior USDJ John T. Curtin )
Notice and copy of order sent to Anthony J. Brock, James R.
Sandner, William D. Maldovan, Andrew P. Fleming (jd)
[Entry date 07/09/01]
8/2/01 61 ORDER, to Extend Time, Response to Motion set to 8/31/01
for [56-1] motion to Dismiss, set to 8/31/01 for [54-1]
motion to Dismiss second amended complaint ( signed by
Senior USDJ John T. Curtin ) Notice and copy of order sent
to Anthony J. Brock, James R. Sandner, William D. Maldovan,
Andrew P. Fleming (jd) [Entry date 08/02/01]
8/24/01 62 ORDER, to Extend Time, Response to Motion set to 9/28/01
for [56-1] motion to Dismiss, set to 9/28/01 for [54-1]
motion to Dismiss second amended complaint ( signed by
Senior USDJ John T. Curtin ) Notice and copy of order sent
to Anthony J. Brock, James R. Sandner, William D. Maldovan,
Andrew P. Fleming (jd) [Entry date 08/24/01]
9/27/01 63 MEMORANDUM of LAW by plaintiffs in opposition to [56-1]
motion to Dismiss by William E. Scheuerman, United
Professions and [54-1] motion to Dismiss second amended
complaint by Walter J. Pellegrini, Allen C. DeMarco,
Michael P. Rowan, Linda Agnello, State of New York (jd)
[Entry date 09/28/01]
9/27/01 64 AFFIDAVIT by Leland C. Marsh on behalf of plaintiffs (jd)
[Entry date 09/28/01]
9/27/01 65 AFFIDAVIT by plaintiff Paul Zarembka in opposition to
[56-1] motion to Dismiss by William E. Scheuerman, United
Professions, [54-1] motion to Dismiss second amended
complaint by Walter J. Pellegrini, Allen C. DeMarco,
Michael P. Rowan, Linda Agnello, State of New York (jd)
[Entry date 09/28/01]
10/3/01 66 ORDER, if the attorney general desires to file a Reply
that reply shall be filed by 10/19/01, oral argument
shall be held at 10:30am on 12/14/01 ( signed by Senior
USDJ John T. Curtin ) Notice and copy of order sent to
Anthony J. Brock, James R. Sandner, William D. Maldovan,
Andrew P. Fleming (jd) [Entry date 10/03/01]
10/18/01 67 ORDER, granting counsel for defendant New York State
United Teacher's letter request for Extension of Time to
11/19/01 to file reply papers. ( signed by Senior USDJ
John T. Curtin ) Notice and copy of order sent to Anthony
J. Brock, James R. Sandner, William D. Maldovan, Andrew P.
Fleming (jd) [Entry date 10/18/01]
10/23/01 68 ORDER: Court grants request to reschedule oral argument;
Motion Hearing set for 11:30 1/4/02 for [56-1] motion to
Dismiss and [54-1] motion to dismiss second amended
complaint ( signed by Senior USDJ John T. Curtin ) Notice
and copy of order sent to Anthony Brock, James R. Sandner,
William D. Maldovan, Andrew P. Fleming (ds)
[Entry date 10/23/01]
11/15/01 69 ORDER, granting Anthony Brock's letter request for
Extension of Time to 12/7/01 to respond to plaintiffs
affidavits and memorandum of law. ( signed by Senior USDJ
John T. Curtin ) Notice and copy of order sent to Anthony
J. Brock, James R. Sandner, William D. Maldovan, Andrew P.
Fleming (jd) [Entry date 11/15/01]
12/3/01 70 REPLY AFFIDAVIT by Anthony J. Brock counsel for
non-governmental defendants United Professions, William E.
Scheuerman in support of [56-1] motion to Dismiss (jd)
[Entry date 12/03/01]
12/3/01 71 REPLY MEMORANDUM of LAW by non-governmental defendants
United Professions, William E. Scheuerman in support of
[56-1] motion to Dismiss (jd) [Entry date 12/03/01]
12/3/01 72 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by defendants United Professions,
William E. Scheuerman re: [71-1] support memorandum and
[70-1] support affidavit (jd) [Entry date 12/03/01]
12/6/01 73 REPLY MEMORANDUM of LAW by State of New York defendants in
reply to plaintiffs [65-1] opposition affidavit and [63-1]
opposition memorandum (jd) [Entry date 12/07/01]
1/4/02 75 Minute entry: oral argument on defendants motion to
dismiss, decision reserved. JTC (jd) [Entry date 01/15/02]
1/9/02 74 TRANSCRIPT of Motion hearing held before Judge Curtin dated
1/4/02, pages 1-14. (jd) [Entry date 01/09/02]
1/17/02 76 ORDER granting defendants [56-1] and [54-1] motions to
Dismiss based on lack of subject matter jurisdiction and
failure to state a cause of action without prejudice.
signed by Senior USDJ John T. Curtin ) Notice and copy of
order sent to James R. Sandner, Anthony J. Brock, William
D. Maldovan, Andrew P. Fleming (jd) [Entry date 01/18/02]
1/18/02 77 JUDGMENT for defendants State of New York, George E.
Pataki, United Professions, William E. Scheuerman, NYS
United Teachers, Linda Agnello, Michael P. Rowan, Allen C.
DeMarco, Walter J. Pellegrini against Paul Zarembka,
Georgiana H. Jungels (Clerk). Notice and copy of judgment
sent to James R. Sandner, Anthony J. Brock, William D.
Maldovan, Andrew P. Fleming (jd) [Entry date 01/18/02]
1/18/02 -- Case closed (jd) [Entry date 01/18/02]
2/19/02 78 NOTICE OF APPEAL by Paul Zarembka, Georgiana H. Jungels .
Fee Status: Paid $105. (copies to James Sander, Anthony
Brock, William Maldovan and to Clerk USCA with copies of
docket entries. ) (USCA forms C and D mailed to Andrew
Fleming) (jd) [Entry date 02/21/02]